Nostalgia is a funny thing. The most insignificant of objects can send you down the nostalgia highway – a signed yearbook, a prom tiara, a box of pictures, a hand-written letter, a token of someone’s affection – all ticking time bombs of evocative sentiment just itching to send you merging into bumper-to-bumper traffic.
As I general rule, I maintain, women are more nostalgic then men. Whether that’s because we’re more affective beings, have better memories, or just emote more efficiently, we venture down this road more frequently than our male counterparts. Maybe it’s just the men I know, but, with a few exceptions, many of them like to live in the “now” without much regard to the “then” or the “will be.” It’s true, some of their “nows” largely resemble their “thens” and maybe that’s part of it, but for the most part they seem content and, well, forgetful. The women I know are much more reflective on where they’ve come from, what they’re doing, and where they want to go. This concept is pretty much at the forefront of my mind every single day of my life. I always joke that my mind is a sponge because I remember very minute details about things that were trivial in the first place. Maybe that’s why I’m such a nostalgic person.
I, myself, find myself involved in some sort of nostalgic process on a daily basis. It’s not that I’m unhappy with my current lot in life; on the contrary, I’m really quite pleased with the way things have been going. My issue is that stupid, everyday things make me nostalgic. It’s that damn sponge. Things like yellow Post-it notes, coffee creamer, and candied popcorn conjure up a whole batch of memories that inevitably push me into a larger sequence of reminiscence.
I simply cannot look at a yellow Post-it note on a wall without thinking of my freshman year of college. My roommate and I used them to decorate the wall above our telephone (yes, land line) with people’s phone numbers and messages for one another. This quickly evolved into a forum for the comers and goers of our room (ah, dorm life) to leave pithy comments, cryptic notes, and perverted dialogue to entertain us. We let them cumulate, and after a year’s time we had a rather impressive collection. I’m pretty sure I saved a few of the more disturbing ones, but then again, I’m a sucker for sentiment. I’ll bet you my roomie doesn’t even remember this; it was pretty inconsequential in the grand scheme of things a college freshman has to deal with – I’ll have to ask her and get back to you.
A similar chain reaction happens to me every morning when I systematically retrieve my non-dairy creamer from the break room at my office. I simply cannot do this without fondly remembering a morning ritual a good friend of mine and I had while working at a casino in Las Vegas. I would arrive, 5 minutes late as usual, and we would immediately retreat to the Employee Dining Room to steal mugs of CoffeeMate. Now this was completely against the rules, so we’d have to sneak these mugs halfway across the casino back to our office and into our coffees, and then surreptitiously dispose of the evidence. Did I mention we worked in HR? Our boss would not have approved.
A recent stint with nostalgia (well, aside from this morning’s run for coffee creamer) was during a conversation with my ex-honey, and I started to get those same funny old feelings about a city that I came to practically abhor in my final six months living there. The funny thing was that it was a conversation about “sweet popcorn” that made me nostalgic. Lately I’ve become accustomed to getting beer and actual cooked meals at the movie theater (yay, Drafthouse!), but in that moment I wanted nothing more than to go to the Southpoint Casino and go to the movies for the sole purpose of sharing a bag of overpriced, disgustingly sweet, candied popcorn with said ex-honey. Imagine that, after five years of living there, all it took to muster sweet feelings about Las Vegas was a memory of candied popcorn. Go figure.
Nostalgia doesn’t necessarily mean you are yearning for the way things were – I have no desire to live in the dorms, work in a casino, or move back to Vegas again – but it does make me feel fondly about these times. Through the reflective lens of hindsight, the negatives fall away and all you remember are the good. It becomes too easy to forget that the dorms were impossibly cramped and noisy, and our neighbors constantly piped smoke into our room through the conjoining air vent. Coffee creamer runs become more important than the tyranny, 12-hour work days, and abject fear that casino life subjected me to. Sweet popcorn becomes paramount to a society devoid of culture except for the extravagant indulgence of the strip set against an insipid background of identical subdivisions and desert scenery.
My nomadic tendencies have caused me to leave so much behind over the years, so I suppose nostalgia is my only means of holding on to the good stuff. It reminds me that I have a past full of rich experiences and good memories with friends and family and loved ones. But I fear that nostalgia can also be destructive. If you’re not careful, it can cause all the “what if’s” and “what if not’s” to emerge from the framework until that’s all you can see. If you are trying to move forward and find yourself unable, nostalgia may just be your culprit.
It’s a fine line. If we are too quick to forget, any lessons gleaned from our past are lost with it and we are doomed to make the same mistakes over and over again. If we hold on too tightly, it can blind us to new ways of thinking and the opportunities presenting themselves to us in the present. Nostalgia may be an exercise of the memory, but it makes us forgetful too. That which was bad no longer seems as such, the mundane and quotidian suddenly seem “charming” and charged with new meaning, and any pain you felt is replaced by a pang for “simpler times” because it just doesn’t feel real any more.
The jury is still out on whether I think nostalgia is ultimately a productive or destructive process. Taking a trip down memory lane may seem harmless enough, but be careful; one wrong turn and you might miss your exit.
